Current:Home > ContactACC lawsuit against Clemson will proceed after North Carolina judge denies motion to stay -ValueCore
ACC lawsuit against Clemson will proceed after North Carolina judge denies motion to stay
View
Date:2025-04-16 08:06:32
The Atlantic Coast Conference earned a legal victory against Clemson on Wednesday.
North Carolina chief business court judge Louis A. Bledsoe III denied the school's motion to stay and rejected, in part, its motion to dismiss the conference's countersuit. His decision came after a hearing between both parties on July 2 at the Mecklenburg County Courthouse in Charlotte.
Bledsoe's denial of Clemson's motion to stay — a stay is a ruling by a court to stop or suspend a proceeding or trial temporarily or indefinitely — means the ACC's lawsuit against Clemson in North Carolina will proceed. He also ruled the arguments over who owns Clemson's' TV rights if it leaves the conference and the penalty for withdrawal from the ACC will proceed in litigation.
Bledsoe rejected Clemson's motion to dismiss on "sovereign immunity" grounds, also, writing Clemson "waived" that by engaging in commercial activities, rather than governmental activities, in North Carolina.
"The only court that has jurisdiction over FSU, Clemson, and the ACC — and thus the only court that can assure a consistent, uniform interpretation of the Grant of Rights Agreements and the ACC’s Constitution and Bylaws, the determinations at the core of the Pending Actions — is a North Carolina court," wrote Bledsoe, who cited conflicting conclusions in different courts would create "procedural chaos and tremendous confusion."
"Only a North Carolina court, most likely in a single consolidated action in North Carolina, can render consistent, uniform determinations binding the ACC, FSU, and Clemson concerning the documents that are at issue in all four Pending Actions."
This gives a perceived home-court advantage to the ACC, but it doesn't mean a North Carolina court's ruling will supersede a South Carolina ruling, if that happens.
Bledsoe dismissed many of the ACC's claims like the league seeking declaration about whether the conference's grant of rights agreements are "valid and binding contracts." He also rejected the league's arguments that Clemson breached its contract with the league, that the school did not act in good faith with the conference's constitution and that it owes fiduciary responsibilities to the conference.
Following Wednesday's ruling, the ACC released the following statement:
"We are pleased with today's ruling as it confirms that only a North Carolina court can render a decision that would apply to both Clemson and Florida State. The opinion also reinforces what the ACC has clearly articulated from day one - the North Carolina courts are the proper place to enforce and interpret the ACC's arguments."
A Clemson's athletic department spokesperson on Wednesday said the university has no comment on the ruling.
There are now three court battles happening between the ACC and Florida State, respectively, and the league's countersuit against Clemson.
Another could join them when Clemson and the ACC have a hearing July 12 at the Pickens County Courthouse. Judge Perry H. Gravely will rule on the university's motion for summary judgement and the conference's motion to dismiss.
The legal battle started March 19 after the university filed its initial complaint against the conference in Pickens County over the conference's grant of rights deal and withdrawal penalty. The decision was seen as an initial legal step to potentially depart the conference to join the SEC or Big Ten. The ACC responded a day later with its countersuit in Mecklenburg County.
veryGood! (236)
Related
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- PACCAR, Hyundai, Ford, Honda, Tesla among 165k vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
- Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb signs proclamation condemning antisemitism while vetoing bill defining it
- Pair accused of defrauding, killing Washington state man who went missing last month
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Former Vice President Mike Pence calls Trump's Jan. 6 hostage rhetoric unacceptable
- Icelandic volcano erupts yet again, nearby town evacuated
- Women's NCAA Tournament 2024: Full schedule, times, how to watch all March Madness games
- Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
- Afghan refugee convicted of murder in a case that shocked Albuquerque’s Muslim community
Ranking
- Former longtime South Carolina congressman John Spratt dies at 82
- Open seat for Chicago-area prosecutor is in voters’ hands after spirited primary matchup
- DAY6 returns with 'Fourever': The album reflects who the band is 'at this moment'
- Federal court rules firearm restrictions on defendants awaiting trial are constitutional
- Intellectuals vs. The Internet
- Is the Great Resignation over? Not quite. Turnover stays high in these industries.
- 2 Black men tortured by Mississippi officers call for toughest sentences
- Full transcript of Face the Nation, March 17, 2024
Recommendation
What were Tom Selleck's juicy final 'Blue Bloods' words in Reagan family
Rob Lowe's son John Owen trolls dad on his 60th birthday with a John Stamos pic
United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby vows to keep passengers safe after multiple mishaps
2 dead, 5 wounded in mass shooting in Washington, D.C., police say
Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
Former Mississippi Archives and History department leader Elbert Hilliard dies at age 87
Garrison Brown’s Close Friend Calls for Sister Wives To Be Canceled After His Death
Missing NC mother, 2 young children found murdered in Charlotte, suspect arrested: Police